On Nov. 3, we got our first look at the 2025 finalists for each award. Aaron Judge could bring home the Yankees’ 23rd MVP Award — the most for any team. On the pitching side, Tarik Skubal might capture the Tigers’ seventh Cy Young Award, which would tie for the most for any American League team. That is, unless Garrett Crochet gives the Red Sox their eighth Cy winner.
Of course, some teams have had bigger hauls than others over the years. What follows is a breakdown of each of the 30 franchise winners in those four categories.
It’s worth noting that these awards cover different time frames. There have been AL and NL Manager of the Year Awards since 1983, AL and NL Cy Young Awards since 1967 (there was a single MLB award from 1956-66), AL and NL Rookie of the Year Awards since 1949 (there was a single MLB award from 1947-48), and AL and NL MVP Awards since 1931. (While MVP Awards did exist in different forms before then, we are not including those here; the current version was established in 1931.)